Top 10 Tips for Choosing the Right Web Design Agency Without Losing Your Sanity or Your Lunch Money

Let’s face it: For most people, choosing a website design agency is right up there with buying a used car or picking a paint color called “Eggshell Whisper”  — strangely overwhelming and full of bold promises you’re not sure you can trust.

You want a website that turns heads for the right reasons, loads faster than a squirrel’s attention span, and doesn’t look like time traveled from the days of dial up modems. 

But with a million agencies out there and each one claiming to be the best since sliced bandwidth, how do you know who’s on point and who’s just really good banter and buzzwords?

Feeling overwhelmed? Breathe. Relax. Read on. Kode is here and we’ve got your back (and your front-end) covered.

We’re going to break this down with no jargon and no nonsense, just 10 solid tips that to help you choose a web design agency that won’t make you want to cry into your keyboard or smash your mouse Hulk style.

‍

1: Spy on Their Portfolio Like You’re in a Gumshoe Movie

Before you hire a web agency, don’t just browse their website, go full on detective mode. An agency’s portfolio is their greatest hits album, except you’re not just looking for catchy tunes that make you want to dance.

You’re looking for variety, originality, and proof that they don’t just copy-paste content from other websites with fancier fonts. Bonus points if their past work makes you say “Ooh” out loud.

‍

2: Pretty is Good. Functional is Better. Both? Jackpot.

Websites aren’t just supposed to be pretty. They should work. Like, really work no matter where you’re using them. On your phone, on your grandma’s iPad, on that weird fridge that has wifi. Your website should work everywhere, full stop.

Click through a few of their sample sites. If you end up lost in a maze of broken buttons and mysterious menus, that’s a glaring red flag that tells you to keep moving before you get caught up in a source code situationship.

‍

3: Grill Them on Their Expertise (Not Literally Grill)

Your chosen agency should know their tech like Gordon Ramsay knows his kitchen. Whether it’s WordPress, Shopify, custom code, or some futuristic platform that sounds made up, they should be fluent.

Not sure what any of that means? That’s okay. Just make sure they do.

‍

4: Read the Reviews. All of Them. Even the Weirdly Angry Ones.

Client reviews are like online dating bios for businesses — equal parts helpful and mildly terrifying and occasionally, very, very cringe.

Check Google, Yelp, Clutch, or wherever your potential designer hangs out. Look for patterns: do clients rave about communication, delivery times, or their ability to read minds? All good signs. 

‍

And yes, one grumpy review doesn’t mean you’re headed down a dark path, but a bunch? Run.

‍

5: Talk to Real Humans Who’ve Worked with Them.

This is your permission slip to be nosy — ask for references and actually call them. Ask them important questions like:

• Were they on time?
• Did they ghost you halfway through?
• Did your website design make you cry tears of joy or misery?

‍

Remember, you’re not just hiring a service, you’re entering a (temporary) creative relationship, and trust matters.

‍

6: Communication: It’s Not Exciting, but It’s Everything

You want an agency that talks to you. Regularly, and in actual human sentences. Get clear answers by asking: Who will I talk to? How often? By phone, email, or smoke signals?

If their idea of communication is disappearing for three weeks and then sending you 47 files named “final-FINAL-V2-really-this-time.psd” — keep walking.

‍

7: Industry Experience: Optional, but Delicious

Do they have experience in your niche? Great. That means they might already understand your audience, lingo, and what not to put on your homepage (e.g. a random stock photo of two people high-fiving).

If they’ve never worked in your field before — that’s okay too. Just make sure they’re curious, adaptable, and not afraid to ask good questions.

‍

8: Look for Signs of Life (AKA Passion)

This one’s more of a vibe check. Are they excited about your project? Do they ask thoughtful questions? Or do they sound like they’re reciting answers from a dusty FAQ?

Creativity comes with curiosity. You want people who want to build something awesome with you.

‍

9: Beware the Budget Black Hole

Let’s talk money. A good agency is clear about pricing. A great agency explains what you’re getting and why it matters. A sketchy one? They’ll give you a quote with fewer details than a spy movie.

Ask what’s included. Ask what’s not. No surprises = good surprises.

‍

10: Trust Your Gut. And Your Browser History.

If something feels off, it probably is. If something feels right? Dig deeper. The best agency for you isn’t necessarily the flashiest. It’s the one that gets your goals, respects your time, and makes the whole process feel just a little more fun than you expected.

‍

A Final Word From Kode

Web design isn’t magic. But when you find the right team? It can feel like it.

Choose wisely. Build boldly. And remember: your website is often your first impression. Make it one worth remembering (in a good way).

‍